Netflix has been on a tear lately with documentaries about Matthew Perry and Martin Mull, but more anticipated was Judd Apatow's Norm: The Tale of Norm McDonald. Assembled solely from clips from his various shows, podcasts, specials, and naturally his years at Saturday Night Live, it mimics the format of people going down a YouTube rabbit hole of related videos on a subject, right down to search box entries and scrolling results.
Augmented with Norm's audiobook reading of his 2017 "memoir novel" Based on a True Story: Not a Memoir, you immediately get the feeling that Macdonald is an unreliable narrator to his life as he'd make claims that he never went to college only to have video shown of him performing in college. It's compounded by Apatow showing a slew of clips of Macdonald saying he's "deeply closeted" while showing he had a son in 1992, but completely omits the fact he was married for a decade in favor of Googling for whether he dated Sports Illustrated swimbo cover girl Elle McPherson. So, Judd, are you saying Norm was gay or not. (NTTIAWWT)
A period where Norm seemed to put on a lot of weight is commented on by showing Reddit posts theorizing that he was puffy from steroids administered for health reasons, potentially cancer (it's revealed he survived stomach cancer in the 1980s), but it illuminates how privately Norm kept his private life private. (Not covered is how his peers felt betrayed by his passing without knowing he was sick, presuming they'd be left out of the loop only to discover as they talked amongst themselves that virtually no one knew he was sick.)
We get a taste of Norm's making-his-own-fun methods and how his peers respected him with a clip from the notorious Comedy Central roast of Bob Saget, who had directed Norm's movie Dirty Work. While modern roasts are generally marked by cruel and nasty putdowns, Norm's routine was mostly incredibly lame lines from an old book of retirement party jokes his father had given him. The audience was sitting there stone-faced, wondering WTF was going on, but the comedians on the stage are doubled-over at the ballsy stunt Norm was pulling. (Video discussing the roast here.)
I read a review of this complaining that if you're someone (like the reviewer) who has gone deep down the YouTube rabbit hole to watch clips of Norm that there isn't much new here. While I've watched a few things of his - I highly recommend finding the compilations of O.J. Simpson jokes which get so brutal and ran for so long the question become not why did they fire him, but how did he manage to survive so long? - there was plenty I haven't seen, but even I could tell it's missing stuff. (The clip from Jerry Seinfeld's Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee omits Norm's savage line about Bill Cosby.)
The rabbit hole metaphor is apt here because Apatow presents the clips as if filming a screen as someone searches for bits and scrolls YouTube and other sites. From a technical standpoint, the audio levels are unbalanced and uneven and there's no excuse for that. No, it doesn't matter that people upload dodgy quality stuff in violation of copyright which is inconsistently enforced, there are ways to normalize and EQ audio to make it consistent.
It's fitting that the word "tale" is in the title of Norm: The Tale of Norm McDonald for a tale is defined as "a narrative that relates the details of some real or imaginary event, incident, or case; story." Pretty much.
Score: 7/10. Catch it on Netflix.






